The right to health is justiciable in some degree analyzing from the three angles of its nature, the limited resource and the separation of powers.
As the two leaders of the France Enlightenment, Montesquieu put forward "separation of powers" theory, Rousseau put forward "popular sovereignty" theory.
"Pressure is growing both inside and outside the government, with genuine political reforms, including accountability and transparency and separation of powers, sorely needed, " he wrote.
The decision was not unanimous; three justices dissented, justice Harlan roundly attacking his six colleagues for violating another basic American principle-separation of powers.
Many opposition deputies boycotted the event, held at the palace of Versailles, once Louis XIV's royal seat, on the grounds that it breached the principle of the separation of powers.
The Supreme Court found the Act unconstitutional, declaring that separation of powers principles prevent Congress from taking "an active role in the supervision of officers charged with the execution of the laws it enacts."
